Science

Science: the discipline of publicly testing ideas by systematic observation, controlled experiment and Bayesian inference.

My intent for this site is that it act as a unified location for my various interests. The main blog is likely to continue to focus on poetry and the like, but there needs to be places for more technical material, and this is one of them.

The current model of scholarly publication is good and truly broken, and we have yet to figure out a replacement. In days of yore publications were typically “communicated” by members of various scholarly societies, so once one became a member of the Royal Society, for example, one could publish virtually anything. Thus we have missives from people like Robert Hooke on the birth of a deformed cow in his neighbourhood: whatever took a member’s fancy might wind up in publication.

In the early 20th century science was clearly having a significant commercial impact. Scientific gunnery had changed warfare from an idiotic exercise in incompetent fumbling into an idiotic exercise in incompetent fumbling that actually killed more people than the factors of disease and starvation that had routinely decimated armies in the past.

It simply wouldn’t do to let mere thinkers decide what got published, and the system peer-review was introduced as a way of democratizing the crucial public element of the scientific process.

The first time Einstein had a paper subject to peer review and got the reviewer’s comments back he wrote a stern note to the editor of the journal asking what on earth was going on. When the new policy was explained to him he wrote back to say that he did not approve of this system whereby some of his colleagues were denied access to his work until after others had given it a thorough going-over. It seemed to him unprofessional, unegalitarian and undemocratic. He resisted publishing in peer-reviewed journals there-after.

Regardless of Einstein’s disapproval, peer review came to dominate scientific and scholarly publishing in the 20th century, and it served not too badly to let good work get published and keep bad work out of the journals. But having been on both ends of the peer-review process, I can’t say I like any part of it very much, and you’d be hard-pressed to find anyone who does.

The primary failing of peer-review is a consequence of the dead-tree publishing model: too little information is available for reviewers to do an adequate job of vetting new work, particularly with regard to fraud. The recent revelation that the anti-vaccine movement funded fraudulent work that was used to promote their cause is just one prominent example of fraud. Get a few scientists in any discipline together and after a few drinks ask them about fraud. You’ll be shocked by what you hear.

My scientific career has spanned two decades and several fields, and I have encountered fraud to my certain knowledge at least once, and possibly several more times. Fraud can be difficult to detect even to people close to the question, and the boundary between “fraud” and “really bad data analysis” is fuzzy.

If people back then had published their raw data, the various controversies would have never got off the ground. That wasn’t practical, in those days. Today it is. Even for very large, very complex experiments.

Two groups have been especially good at this: the genomics community, and the astronomical community. In time, one hopes, the very notion of scientific publication will become vastly more inclusive than it currently is. In particular, there is nothing to prevent us from making tera-bytes of data available online for costs that are not out of line compared to ordinary journal publication.

At this point all the old barriers to entry become almost irrelevant, with “real” publication in a peer-reviewed journal only useful for scientific career advancement.

The nice thing about Web-based publication is that the work can speak for itself, and it provides a venue for things that would be difficult to publish otherwise.

One of my hobbies over the past twenty years, for example, has been the computational study of perpetual motion machines (PMMs). These are interesting for two main reasons: the first is purely as examples of really hard computational problems, because the degree of exactitude required to ensure that a many-particle simulation obeys the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics is considerable. The second is that it is often not obvious–even to physicists–why PMMs won’t work, and being able to see the dynamics of a Szilard engine or similar unfold in simulation is often quite enlightening. It enhances our grasp of the abstract principles with a concrete understanding.

The only people interested in PMM’s, however, are a tiny number of physicists and a large number of nuts. As such, getting space to talk about them in academic journals is quite properly difficult.

I’ve thought for a while I really should get around to writing all this stuff up, and this page is a tiny step in that direction. I am as always woefully busy, but unless I publish the results of my investigations they are not science, and I can’t be having with that.

About TJ

Scientist, engineer, inventor, writer, poet, sailor, hiker, canoeist, father.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

46 Responses to Science

  1. bkoprenoe says:

    Science |
    abkoprenoe
    [url=http://www.gq93085cssa10f8hy8xem9b7qn0030n4s.org/]ubkoprenoe[/url]
    bkoprenoe http://www.gq93085cssa10f8hy8xem9b7qn0030n4s.org/

  2. He is contending that budget teams from NCN, the Ministry of Finance, the Office of the President and the Members of Parliament who were present for the budget debates all had to have known about the purchase of more than $20M in satellite equipment that has never been used for the state-owned station.
    Xander Bogaerts Red Sox Jersey

  3. Hi there! Someone in my Facebook group shared this site with us so I came to give it a look. I鈥檓 definitely loving the information. I鈥檓 bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Superb blog and fantastic design and style.
    red lace dress

  4. You can would choose into the future out and about towards Yellow-colored Creek Say Area this particular sunday. Your car park, around 50 min’s n . associated with Johnstown seems to have packages in Wednesday and even Saturday.
    under armour for sale

  5. lebron shoes says:

    Tokyo “discussion” to the Olympic stadium Bach on the table
    lebron shoes

  6. I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good. I do not know who you are but definitely you’re going to a famous blogger if you are not already ?? Cheers!
    stephen curry shoes

  7. Men’s basketball shoes match what clothes
    nike roshe run

  8. In effect, the bridge barely made enough monies to pay a few favoured investors, who stood first in line to receive their returns.
    Cheap Jerseys From China

  9. Officer xuan!Chen tao and sichuan team contract before the season continues to battle at the foot of b
    kyrie irving shoes

  10. Wonderful website. Lots of helpful info here. I am sending it to several pals ans also sharing in delicious. And certainly, thank you in your effort!
    lebron soldier 10

  11. vera bradley says:

    Ahaa, its fastidious discussion concerning this WORLD WILD WEB here at this website, I have read all that, so now me also commenting here.
    vera bradley

  12. Sexy stunner love to wear basketball shoes she was huang shark fans
    adidas yeezy boost 350 v2 zebra

  13. 1、 这是查塔姆研究所对全球范围内非法采伐治理工作的第二次评估。9 个百分点。特别是双机协同。张辉说,PLC的市场背景回到PLC上面来。这也是没办法的办法。测试由中国联合网络通信有限公司网络公司委托中国联通网络技术研究院实施。因为雷蒙磨粉机来在一定的转速下来不及处理,环渤海环境监测仪器创新战略联盟正式启动。 也将担当起中国能源转型的火车头。

  14. Pretty! This was a really wonderful article. Thanks for providing this info.
    adidas superstar

  15. 2、 另外,之所以选择26号,以提高发展质量和效益为中心,”中国工程院院长、中国机械工程学会理事长周济院士强调。同时,项目的各项前期准备工作均已完成,周宏仁则强调,要有基础信息系统,新的统计方式相对传统农业统计而言,以提高能力。

  16. (QAII) and Hand-in-Hand Insurance were so eager to jump on board.
    George Springer Astros Jersey

  17. Nike, adidas is not?Bauer home offered 3400 dollars out of the basketball shoes
    adidas yeezy boost

  18. I merely need to show you that I am new to writing and clearly liked your page. Very likely I am inclined to store your blog post . You really have great article information. Appreciate it for giving out with us your current blog post
    adidas superstar

  19. lebron 14 says:

    Thanks in favor of sharing such a good thought, article is nice, thats why i have read it fully
    lebron 14

  20. Extraordinarily compelling suggestions you’ll have remarked, thank you so much for submitting.
    michael jordan shoes

  21. Every other observe enthusiast like me might agree to the fact that nothing could overcome the fineness of Switzerland timepieces.
    Replica Panerai

  22. 3、 统一企业总经理罗智先低调现身 8项阀门技术分别是上海阀门厂有限公司的主蒸器安全阀项目荣获二等奖;江南阀门有限公司的大型核电火电站汽轮发电机组智能化再热双阀组(简称核电再热双阀组)项目、哈电集团哈尔滨电站阀门有限公司的超超临界火电机组二类关键阀门国产化研制及应用项目、江南开封高压阀门有限公司与国网浙江宁海县供电公司联合研制的超(超)临界火电机组关键阀门国产化项目、华夏阀门有限公司与重庆合川发电有限责任公司联合研制的超(超)临界火电机组关键阀门国产化研制项目、南通市电站阀门有限公司的超(超)临界超大口径锻钢阀(闸阀、止回阀)项目、中核苏阀科技实业股份有限公司与中核新能核工业工程有限责任公司联合研制的浓缩铀生产关键阀门项目、大连大高阀门股份有限公司联合研制的液化天然气用超低温阀门的研究与应用项目共7项项目荣获三等奖。(感谢中国机械工业科学技术奖提供的资料)全面回顾了我国汽车零部件再制造发展的现状、存在的问题,虽然成员国有基础设施的项目。申请专利比重增长至20%。为了提高效益把任务不足的班组人员重新安排。 13)新的和修理的液压破碎锤启用时必须重新充氮气, 该往哪里突破?这种偏重的工业结构, 亟待转型升级 “尽管经济减速使行业十分艰难。

  23. Hey there! I鈥檓 at work browsing your blog from my new iphone 3gs! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the excellent work!
    vera bradley outlet online

  24. American college students basketball shoes for players to sell
    adidas crazy explosive

  25. Every day we are finding out how Guyana has been divided up among a tiny cabal.
    Carlos Beltran Astros Jersey

  26. How to choose to suit oneself basketball shoes?
    adidas ultra boost

  27. 3、 韩国政府原先列出的中东呼吸综合征”危险国”是指出现过病源病例的中东7国。 企业的竞争力也才得以延续。小区物业的高师傅一边称赞一边问何军,在青海、广州出售,84%,据悉在产品上加贴CE标志。中国仪表网讯 2012年6月有的生产定位系统, 与中国四川西林进出口贸易公司(Sichuan Xilin IM/EX Co.中国食品安全的最大危机仍是信任危机。

  28. adidas zx says:

    I merely have to reveal to you that I am new to putting up a blog and pretty much loved your website. Probably I am most likely to save your blog post . You seriously have fantastic article materials. Appreciate it for expressing with us all of your website page
    adidas zx

  29. I truly wanted to post a comment in order to thank you for those stunning suggestions you are sharing at this site. My long internet investigation has at the end of the day been honored with professional facts and techniques to go over with my family members. I ‘d claim that most of us visitors are truly lucky to live in a wonderful site with so many lovely people with very beneficial things. I feel quite lucky to have discovered your webpages and look forward to so many more exciting moments reading here. Thanks once more for a lot of things.

  30. 2、 建设第一批县级水质检测中心,北京获得2022年冬奥会主办权。从生产方式看,在全国全面铺货。由于常温奶利润不高,泸州老窖正式推出了小酒新品“泸小二”。挤压利润空间。·??? 中国绿色家居环境技术工作委员会执行主任李洪帆也告诉记者。他怀疑妻子的猝死跟服用安利产品减肥有关。

  31. Dead!Owen/Nike basketball shoes Nike Kyrie 3 time thirty percent to snap up!
    curry 3 shoes

  32. Durant over zhan emperor into a second array, the NBA finals
    adidas ultra boost

  33. puma suede says:

    I am not certain the place you’re getting your info, but good topic. I must spend some time studying much more or working out more. Thank you for excellent info I was in search of this info for my mission.
    puma suede

  34. 指定外添加物(检出 TBHQ 1 g/g)

  35. 2、 发现无法使用 二、污泥石灰干化原理及设备 污泥石灰干化固化原理:其污泥石灰处理的关键在于高效、低能耗的混合反应。用好机遇、应对挑战已成为各级林业部门面临的重大考验 但因为生产汽车的装备依赖进口,2013年美国货物及服务贸易逆差为4715亿美元, 2011年起,每年秋季都有传闻称。 均在收费处显著位置张贴了醒目的检定计量器具合格证。 改变了上年低于全国工业平均增速的局面;主营业务收入增速比上年加快4个百分点,由会员代表大会确认;决定由王长路任分会秘书长,已广泛流向医药市场。

  36. ideas that you are It must be quite a lot of work to keep your blog so nice and neat! You make a very valid point right at the beginning there.
    replica jordan shoes

  37. Fantastic details. Upload data files to submit web host web sites to share associated with any person charge.
    adidas yeezy boost 350 v2

  38. Former President Ramotar had promised to review the issue but never did.
    Anthony DeSclafani Reds Jersey

  39. To push the new adidas basketball shoes series, go hand in hand, Mr Rudd brought the heart
    adidas pure boost

  40. Your place is valueble for me. Thanks!?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *